Air-Fryer Twice-Baked Potatoes
Russet potatoes baked, scooped, mashed with sour cream, butter, cheddar, and crispy bacon, restuffed into their skins, returned to the air fryer to brown on top. The steakhouse side, on a Tuesday, with chives.
The twice-baked potato is the steakhouse side that nobody makes at home because of its perceived effort. Bake the potato, scoop it out, mash the inside, restuff it, bake it again — it does sound like a project. But the project is mostly waiting, which the air fryer cuts in half. First bake: 40 minutes at 380°F (vs. 60 in the oven). Second bake: 8 minutes. The total time is just over an hour, but only fifteen minutes of that is hands-on, and the result is the most respectable potato side dish there is.
The photo shows the finish: three halves on a gray plate, the filling piled mountainous and topped with sharp cheddar that's melted into the crevices, crispy bacon crumbles, fresh chives. The skin underneath is still crisp from the first bake. You break through the cheese into the soft mash and find streaks of bacon and onion — it's a baked potato that decided to become a casserole.
A note on the potato: russets are non-negotiable for this. Yukon golds turn waxy when twice-baked; sweet potatoes are a different recipe. You want the dry, fluffy texture that russets give you when their interior has been mashed with dairy fat.
Method
ii.-
01
First bake
Pierce each potato several times with a fork. Rub all over with olive
-
02
Cool slightly and halve
Let the potatoes cool 10 minutes — long enough that you can handle
-
03
Scoop the filling
Using a spoon, scoop the soft interior into a bowl, leaving a ¼-inch
-
04
Mash the filling
To the bowl, add the butter, sour cream, half the cheddar, half the
-
05
Restuff
Pile the filling back into the four potato shells, mounded high. Top
-
06
Second bake
Place the stuffed potatoes back in the air fryer at 400°F (200°C) for
-
07
Finish and serve
Scatter the remaining chives (and scallions, if using) over the top